It was my first time going to Massey Hall and I got a bit lost as a result. I emerged from the correct exit from Queen Station, but without something as handy as a map, and took the long way around by walking around the block.
Part of the confusion stemmed from having the wrong expectation as to its size. When founded my guesstimate by using Roy Thomson Hall as a reference, which is pretty large and stands alone for the most part. Massey Hall in contrast is much more nondescript and blends in with a cluster of similarly sized brick buildings.
After a bit of thinking, I think I would be partial to going to VGL again were it to come to town. I just wouldn’t pay $80 to do so. And I’d like to hear Kingdom Heart 2’s Passion and maybe some Command and Conquer / Red Alert music, but that’s secondary.
Eighty dollars is a steep price to pay to hear a mix of pre-recorded music and live orchestra. Compound that with the fact that the orchestra rehearsed as a group the day of the performance, and I thought it showed. There were obvious instances where the orchestra was not together either with each other or the pre-recorded bits.
Later, the organizer of the group I “went” with told me something that makes it sound as if the musicians didn’t quite know what they were getting into. I noticed the aftermath, when during one of Martin Leung’s performances one of the cellists got up and left, returning before he finished. It turns out that the piece before, foam that I thought was confetti was sprinkled down on the stage. That cellist found herself constantly pausing to wipe the foam off the cello’s strings, and there’s no telling what effect any liquid exposure could have to a string instrument.
The cellist gave the conductor these dirty looks the whole time and, according to my friend, left to probably chew out the stage manager.
I guess when I hear live orchestra being pitched to me, I immediately set certain standards for things like technical proficiency, co-ordination, and sound balance, and the latter two were sorely missed that night.
The same applies to Martin Leung, as technically accomplished as he is. If you want to get really serious about performance, give the man at least a mic’ed upright piano. A digital keyboard with its flimsy stand, and a typical chair, is not an optimal performance platform. As it was, he was pretty casual on things like hammer octaves, but when things are loud and fast one can pedal things away and the casual fan won’t notice, or just be more impressed with seeing hammer octaves live.
Because I’m a big Hikk-tard, one of the highlights for me was the performance of Hikari known as Simple and Clean for the english version of Kingdom Hearts. The real highlight, though, was the Coronation/Baba Yetu arrangement from Civilization IV. It was far the most inspirational, best integrated with the video game footage since it was all ancient history and epic structure building. Even though the soloist flubbed his part.
After going on YouTube and looking for what a real performance would sound like, I have come to the conclusion that in general it’s a pretty difficult part to pull off. It’s in Swahili, for one, and the sound balance has to be pretty near perfect because it’s not supposed to be too loud. The best performance of this arrangement was from the Hollywood Bowl, and it may have very well been the original game singers present. The next best performance of Baba Yetu isn’t even from VGL (which is kind of sad), but from the Valencia HS choir. The only problem is that the backing orchestra was pretty terrible and on many occasions the interjecting lines come in late.
I think that what with the contest events, video game footage of mostly terrible game play (the Sonic the Hedgehog footage is obviously bad even to those who have never played the games), not so perfect performances, and a bit of rabble rousing from the MC, this was really a kind of fan service for video gamers. VGL caters to the kind that will go to YouTube and watch video game music videos just like how I’d go to YouTube or Stage6 and watch anime music videos.
I’m not putting down those people, but I’m likely to think twice before spending a significant amount of money for something that’s better and free (provided it’s not taken down due to copyright complaint).
Tags: games, music, toronto

Entries (RSS)